**Please note: After posting this review, a representative from Kelty kindly stepped in and informed us of a feature of the pack that we had somehow missed….(amazing how that can happen!) I have revised this post, but did not revise the video (because it is hard to get a house quiet enough to do that with two young kids!) But, we now know that
We have gotten fairly swamped with people wanting a fair comparison between the Kelty Pathfinder 3.0 and the Deuter Kid Carrier III (both packs that we have reviewed previously – links lead to those reviews on this blog.) I am honestly not too keen on comparing the packs because there is certainly a HUGE amount of personal preference, but I also believe in doing real, honest reviews here and so will happily give our opinion! While I personally believe these are two of the very best on the market right now, Osprey’s Poco is starting to hit stores now, and who knows where that one will stand in the line-up! It seems pretty great, but I haven’t tested it myself. I will certainly update this when we do!
|Comparing how far they open up.|
|Comparing widths when compact (this is a revised photo – see note at top of post)|
Let me start with saying that both carriers are excellent. In our family they have both served their purpose and we reach for them for different things and usually for different kids. This is absolutely our personal preference and opinions and the best way for you to make a decision about a carrier is to go into a store and try one on.
If you prefer to watch the comparison (easier to see some of the features…though note that this video is nothing professional! )
What they both do well:
- Ample amount of storage space (1220 Cubic Inches in the Deuter; 1300 Cubic Inches in the Kelty)
- Same weight (7 lb. 10 oz.)
- Area for a hydration bladder
- Plenty of exterior pockets
- Both have sleeping “pillows” for the kids to rest on.
- They retail for a similar price point (Kelty $279; Deuter $299)
- Fold up compact (they are about the same width if you don’t take the removable daypack on the Kelty into consideration – see photo above)
|Deuter Kid Carrier III Hydration|
|Kelty Pathfinder 3.0
Advantages of the Deuter Kid Comfort III (this is the pack J usually rides in):
- Higher back which provides more support and protection for the child.
- Side entry which makes loading easier for bigger kids
- Compresses thinner so despite the length, packs easier; opens up larger to allow for larger kids or more gear (or just easier adjustment.) *The Kelty has a moveable daypack that keeps its width just a little wider*
- Sun shade is a part of the pack and stows away in its own pocket (the Kelty also has a sun shade, but it is much more complicated to set up.)
- Vari-Flex Hip Wings are AWESOME for carrying a heavier child especially. They really do move with your movement and allow the rest of the pack to stay mostly still.
- Seems to accomodate a larger child (J at almost 3 fits in it with his snow gear on still). However, on the other hand, it isn’t so great for small or very young children because they can’t see over it as well.
- We find this pack in general is more comfortable for us when carrying a heavy load (40+ pounds.)
Advantages of the Kelty Pathfinder 3.0 (this is the pack P usually rides in):
- Removable Daypack
- “Roll cage” to protect kids during a fall *This is our very favorite feature of this pack – I truly feel like the child is more protected. However, it also means that it has a limited amount of space to get a kid into because the width is fixed by the roll cage.*
- Excellent support in the shoulder straps (5-point harness). When P was 4 months old (and had superb head control, he could easily sit in it.) We couldn’t put P in the Deuter at all until at least 7 months (but he is a small kid.)
- Easier and quicker to adjust the torso length on the pack (it adjusts with a pin in the waist belt; the Deuter adjusts by moving the shoulder straps.)
- Self-retracting kickstand (or “base”) to help with adjustments (and yes, this base is very secure when loading a child.)
- The sternum strap is much easier to adjust (it is on a “track”)
|The packs they usually ride in|
|They still fit in the “other pack” but not as well…|
If we could choose just one…..
I know this is the question that everyone has, but it really isn’t easy at all to answer and is totally a matter of personal preference. But, hopefully this will help…..
If you are doing activities where you are worried about falling and potentially crushing your child (like skiing)….choose the Kelty
If you want your child to be able to comfortably sit in the carrier at a young age……choose the Kelty.
If you foresee carrying your 3 year old (as long as they + gear are under 50 pounds) or have larger children in general…..choose the Deuter.
And if you just can’t make a decision and it is making you crazy…..choose whichever one you can find on sale OR you can find locally!
Please feel free to leave comments of your own experiences and preferences – we truly want to hear them (and feel as though they are valuable to everyone else reading this post!)